Before diving any deeper into this step, lets revisit requirement 5 for your Eagle Scout Rank: While a Life Scout, plan, develop, and give leadership to others in a service project helpful to any religious institution, any school, or your community.. A scout doesnt have to directly supervise anyone. Advancement & Awards, Advancement & Awards FAQs, Awards and Square Knots, Eagle Palms, Eagle Scout, Leaders, Magazine, Merit Badges, Scouts BSA. I wanted to allow my son to plan his project by himself. Since 1976 we have had 6 Eagles in my family. It only highlights that there is very little guidance which leads to inconsistencies in evaluating what is good enough. As we mentioned earlier, you may want to hold some sort of event to express your gratitude for the volunteers who came out and supported you in completing your project. I dont see how that can be done without redoing the entire service project itself. Now, without further ado, lets jump to where you should be in your planning process the night right before your actual Eagle project, Its 7 PM, the night before your Eagle project and, as the Scout motto says, youve been doing your best to stay prepared! What type of info are you looking for? Sub-leads are typically older scouts or Scoutmasters that you designate to lead a smaller section of your project. New Eagle Scout Honored By Long Valley Mayor - Patch WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF THE EAGLE PROJECT? Recently had a project where the sketch included showed the boy had no clue how to construct it. to demonstrate leadership of others while performing a project for the benefit of their community. If theres one thing I learned from my Eagle Scout Project experience, its that you cant plan for everything. Here are the latest, official versions of Council Eagle forms available to download. No council, district, unit, or individual has the authority to add or change requirements or to require additional forms. No more planning. Being familiarity with the Guide to Advancement, topic 9.0.2.14, "Risk Management and Eagle Scout Projects," and also "Service Project Planning Guidelines" in the Guide to Safe Scouting will be helpful. Theyre the work of hours of analysis meant to prevent injuries. Youve been giving leadership to others since you were the First Class Rank! Another example. Eagle Project Idea Generator - The National Eagle Scout Association Giving and showing leadership to Professionals that actually draw blood? Once things get tough and people stop having fun, the work rarely ever gets done (did you like my rhyme there? Eagle Scouts - Occoneechee Council Starting your Eagle Project . Building, installing, and planting planter boxes at a community theater . (Because of the strict requirements the parents ended up writing most of the projects which defeats the purposes of the Eagle). It seem to me that the new workbook is very easy to understand. For more leadership advice, check out my article on the 5 Deadly Leadership Mistakes to Avoid. If it is not practical to meet these protocols, do not conduct the activity or service project. Six months later the resulting project is an eyesore: the chip board is separating, the paint is peeling, the shelves are falling down, and is not used at all. No. These young men are not licensed construction engineers. Therefore, younger scouts should do safer, less technical tasks, while adults should work on more complex, detailed parts of your project. My son just received his Eagle Badge. My son is 14 and is 10 times more mature than his scoutmaster! More (including web links) are available in the planning guides below. 33088), which is available at Scout Shops and online at scouting.org/filestore/pdf/33088.pdf. Also when approving the proposal it takes about 15 minutes now. Even if after I discuss a project with the scout and understand his idea, I sometimes find that the Eagle advisor or higher levels see the proposal differently than I did and we can have problems. BSA has to spend more time and an overall better job letting us know about UPCOMING changes. It might mean US mentoring and teaching instead of earning knots to go over our left pocket! This log will later be a section of yourEagle Project book. 510-025 2019 Printing Boy Scouts of America 1325 West Walnut Hill Lane P.O. You've prepared as much as possible for this day, and now it's time to put your carefully-laid plans into action! Look for any belongings left by your workers that will need to be returned at a later time. Does this diminish the rank of Eagle Scout? I have seen many projects where if you go back one year later the projects intended use is no longer. If this trend continues it may very well a sign of the decline of scouting. The second is a list of service project planning guidelines that should appear in the Final Plan section of the Eagle . PDF Eagle Scout Process Checklist (follow the 30 Steps) - Alamo Area Council A wink and a nod will do. It was embarrassing and difficult to tell parents in our community that it was an eagle scout project. The workbook must be used throughout the entire process of writing the proposal, developing the plan, and completing the report when the project is finished. There must also be evidence of organized planning and development. When he was done he presented his detailed plan to the Eagle Scout advisor. My son is so frustrated with new 2013 workbook. The Eagle Scout Service Project, or simply Eagle Project, is the opportunity for a Scout (Scouts, B.S.A. Can an Eagle project be a fund raising project in and of itself rather than a building or improvement project? If I had a junior leader who tried to hand write an OPORD from memory I would fire him for being too dumb to use modern tools. I have two issues with the new plan/process. I agree with the posts above. When visiting each volunteer group, you should also appoint sub-leads. Thank you! Thanks so much for reading, and for making our world a better place. Are we dummying down the program and the legacy of all Eagles? As the leader of your project, its your job to keep your volunteers in the loop and excited to help out. The Guide to Safe Scouting provides information applicable to a Scout's Eagle Scout Service Project. It things are too easy scouts will leave, From the projects I have seen scouts enjoy a challenge and put in a great deal of time an effort. This is my problem in my troopI am currently working on my proposal, and am stuck because the adults say come to me when you are ready. Well, youth really need a lot of guidance; this is often the biggest project weve done, and theres a happy medium between no guidance and coddling us. This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Scouts get van under standing of paperwork along with computer work which in many professions happens on a daily basis. Troop 26, Fort Drum, NY. Running an Eagle Scout service project is the final obstacle that separates most scouts from the 5% who rise up to earn their Eagle rank. Have you ever thought about what it means to give leadership to others? Per the BSA Advancements Guide: The Five Tests of an Acceptable Eagle Scout Service Project. This means sending over some emails with clear explanations to any questions that might arise around your project. If youre serving food the day of your project. (To learn more about the Eagle Scout service project, see the Guide to Advancement, topics 9.0.2.0 through 9.0.2.16.) Scouts have long used the Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook to plan and report on their projects. My daughters reached higher goals as Brownies. You must use the Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook, BSA publication No. They expect high standards; they will be disappointed when they find out that the program is not what it should be. Making things too difficult to accomplish will deter many scouts from completing what could be considered a once in a lifetime accomplishment. As an organization, we should really look at developing a high standard a leadership, planning, and service- with a focus on producing quality and not quantity Eagle Scouts. The Eagle coach is a great suggestion. Document Your Project Submit Your Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook and Eagle Binder Discuss Your Project During a Board of Review This article will mainly focus on 'Planning' of your project, phases 1-5, to help you get your idea off the ground. The requirements are the same. How To Plan An Eagle Scout Project: An Easy 5-Step Guide - ScoutSmarts Your Eagle Scout project is the culmination of every lesson you've learned throughout your years in Scouting. Your reward will be a helpful project and, more important, the knowledge you have contributed to a young Scout's growth. From the May-June 2012 issue of Scouting magazine I hope this article has helped simplify the process for you so that youre prepared to do an excellent job! At a certain point, and I think we are close, the Eagle Scout Rank will just become a paper mill award. With that, youve laid the groundwork for a successful Eagle Scout project! My comment is regarding the last note on this page, that training on the changesis being tested. I have been on a regional council for years as well as being on board of reviews and welcomed the new changes. That by becoming an Eagle Scout you really do stand above the rest. It turned out to be a great project, building and installing multiple owl nests for a local nature group, with built in steps to ensure longevity. Plans are shown, Donations are noted. The Distinguished Eagle Scout Award was established in 1969 to acknowledge Eagle Scouts who have distinguished themselves in business, professions, and service to their country. However, I promise youll overcome any challenge and make things work out in the end, so just have some faith in yourself! Eagle Projects. This article is based on the experiences and research of Eagle Scouts, Kevin A, and Cole. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from the site author is strictly prohibited. Getting Eagle brings opportunity with its designation along with responsibility. Eagle Scout Requirement 5: I am the mother of three grown daughters, the sister of two brothers, and the daughter of a scoutmaster. creative and do more than we discuss here. Training on the changes related to the Guide to Advancement 2011 and the Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook has been created and is currently being tested. Ok, so Im a mom of 2 current Cub Scouts and one that will start scouting in 2013. Eagle Scout Information - National Capital Area Council Paint colorful squares for a game of hopscotch on a school playground. The award is given by the National Eagle Scout Service . But back to the main problem which concurs with other comments.lets have a document that is user friendly on computer os changes can be made easily and things like pictures and drawings can be easily inserted into the document and eliminate the needs for appendix or additional pages at the end or in the middle of the document to show progress and completion. Key elements of the process are explained : The Eagle Scout Rank and the Service Project; Typical Projects Over the years over zealous volunteer leaders have unfairly imposed on scouts all kinds of extra requirements and unnecessary details to make the project meet their own descriptions of what they believe the project should entail. ____ 2. 3) Relying on subjective evaluation from an Eagle Board of Review to reject a plan at this stage of the process will they do it, Doubtful. Box 152079 These are dedicated Scouters who care about the program and the young man setting there. We saw it as a process improvement that generated more uniform OPORDs, saved time and allowed leaders to use mental capacity else ware. The rules of replying: Be respectful. Looking back at the changes made over the year a Life Scout no longer has to have final approval before beginning a project. He also consulted the U.S. Department of Labor. With all the merit badge factories in place, and these new watered down eagle project requirements it is actually more difficult to make 1st class then Eagle. (To learn more about the Eagle Scout service project, see the Guide to Advancement, topics 9.0.2.0 through 9.0.2.15.) Why these guidelines exist Reader Dan Rusin of Havre de Grace, Md., sent us a letter to the editor inquiring why the BSA revised the workbooks requirements. Please BSA bring out a proper wordprocessing form of the workbook for the sake of the sanity of Eagle Coaches everywhere! Boy Scoutings most difficult advancement requirementthe Eagle Scout service projectis also its best documented. I appreciate the intent is that the Scout will insert pictures, continue tables etc on additional pages as needed. The form is awful and actually hinders Scouts. There was no time to waste, so to adapt to the new challenge I needed to get resourceful. This is also teaching the scout how to work within parameters that a job application and or format is restrictive. The Final Report -- Guidelines to help you. Young men can progress into a work situation better with having this knowledge an application. When he tried to use the workbook, it had locked the fields. WHERE CAN I LEARN MORE? As a reminder, every Eagle Scout Project is different, so the steps and actions youll need to take might be a bit different from what Im about to outline here. After all, if they dont know whats going on, how can you expect their team to do good work? Some (like me) have opted not to to continue sitting on the Review Boards at all. Not pretty, but it works. 512-927, in meeting this requirement, but that is the new workbook not the old one. Aaron Derr is the senior editor of Aaron on Scouting and Scout Life magazine, and also a former Cubmaster and Scouts BSA volunteer. Or paint a cheerful map of your country or state on the cement. If not, can the task be done by you alone so that your tired volunteers can head home? The B.S.A. After approval, we made sure the materials and ideas were environmetally soundand off to work he went. As a Scoutmaster and District Eagle Project Reviewer, Round table Staff member and with an Eagle Scout Son, Life Scout Son soon to be Eagle and Life Scout myself (I failed my Eagle BOR in 1975 as I lead Non-Scouters and that wasnt accepted and I never performed a 2nd one) I am working with the new system this year and have signed off on at least 10 Proposals so far. To be an Eagle Scout meant you were in a small group of the best of the best. I do not like the new rules but unfortunately that is what we are stuck with now. as a Life Scout said to me the other day this is easy, all I need to do is plan a project and fill in a few spaces, its easier than taking a test in school If that doesnt devalue the rank what does! One followed the spirit of the requirements, one gave the Eagle Scout award to anyone, and one required college level writing and 75+ pages of writeup before they would even look at the proposal. I. This involved sawing, concrete work, leveling 210 and 212 PT lumber 10 in the air, roofing and shingling, etc. I did not approve it asking for more information. The application says you must use the Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook, No. For example, there have been situations in which beneficiaries sought to require last-minute additions before signing off, and others where new management had different ideas about what should have been done. written by Randy Smith (used here with his permission). Eagle Scout Project Fundraising: Tips, Methods, And Guidelines Navigating the Eagle Project for Beneficiaries - Scoutmastercg.com CAN OUR DISTRICT MODIFY THE PROJECT REQUIREMENT? Basically, arriving early will help you and your volunteers to hit the ground running! WHAT SUPPLIES HE NEEDS AND HOW TO GET THEM DONATED. Steps for the Scout. We (troop adult leaders) reviewed the idea and approved proceeding to the planning phase, but expressed concern about the complexity. I am a true believer in that the project must truly benefits the scouts community and will have a lasting value. Did you read the entire workbook before you jumped to a conclusion? It cant be edited easily, it has no advanced typing features like bold, italics, indenting, etc. The first is the age guidelines for the use of hand tools and power tools, working heights and elevations, and excavations. Path." The entire Eagle project is about one thing: You have boys with years of service and leadership the Eagle project PROCESS gives them the tools and experience they would need AS GROWN MEN LATER IN LIFE to see a need in their community and do something about it. Is it ok to contact the district eagle counselor and ask for a review on this project? Since less planning is required, the scouts are prone to try to get ideas approved that arent detailed enough. The advisor did help him with some added info on the rails to his bridge. While this is very rare, know that if you completed the majority of your project plans in good faith, youre not required to organize another work day. Eagle Rank Requirements - U.S. Scouting Service Project But their use should be byadults only (18 and up), according to the guidelines: If something isnt in the list, start by consulting the owners manual for the product. As I see it the book provides clarity that protects the scout from the over-reach of leaders who try to make the project into more than the BSA is asking for. However, a Scout can conduct a money-earning project to pay for project materials. During these challenging times, the Boy Scouts of America needs you more than ever. The proposal allowed him to really plan step-by-step what to do. It is NOT about the plan. Check with your district for the . We then spent many hours looking together for a new project and planning his new proposal. We asked him to finish it before our principal signed off on the project and he pressured our principal into signing it because he needed it signed off by that week and that he could not take it back and complete it because the team would be difficult to gather together again because the actual buildout of the project had been completed in a single day, in 6 hours. This book does not lower the standards but helps the scout to better understand what needs to be accomplished and how. CAN A PROJECT BENEFIT AN INDIVIDUAL? Have a great day! After all the hands-on work for your Eagle project has been completed, all thatll be left to do is project follow-up! It has VERY LITTLE to do with these things. I fear that the current process will allow a Scout to leap out with insufficient planning and get some Scout injured or killed. They do not give they a goal just because they want one. So this Eagle project workbook is new to me. Councils or districts may not require a minimum (or maximum) for the scope of the Eagle Scout service project. I had a scoutmaster tell me there was a MINIMUM of 75 to 100 hours for an Eagle Scout Project. PDF EAGLE PROJECT CHECKLIST - Troop 13 Chester There is a prestige with such a title and to make it easily attainable then it wont be anything special. 24 foot walking bridge and 100 X 4 gravel path complete; and the workbook has built in spell checkreally nice. below. That has not always been the case but in the end I really hope that no Scout I ever advise gets before an Eagle BOR without a complete project plan and gets turned down at their BOR because of that. A candidate has to earn 21 merit badges varying in subject from first aid to business, assume leadership roles and execute a large community service . By choosing reliable sub-leads and briefing them thoroughly, youll be able to successfully delegate out your leadership responsibilities! Im with Joe B. on this. I have seen a number of worthy Scouts quit scouting due to dishonest adults trying to force requirements that are contrary to BSA policy.