Battle Droids defend Desix against the Empire | Star Wars: The Bad A fascist military industrial dictatorship is inherently evil and everyone who props it up or supports it are wrong. Most of the former Republic accepted the Empire without complaint, but there were many bands of resistence fighters and Separatist remnants lurking around the galaxy. Seriously. Many troopers had no idea who they were fighting for, or that it was wrong. - Star Wars: Bloodline, Claudia Gray. To which it was replied that it is expected to punish the entire planet Lothal - a thought that never crossed her mind. Was the Imperial Alliance/Government really that bad? (New to Star Wars In Legends continuity, Grand Moff Bertroff Hissa not only believed that the Empire was evil, but relished in it (with all the ham of a mustache-twirling villain): To my fellow grand moffs, and to the grand admirals, other officers, stormtroopers, bounty hunters, slavelords, and slaves, I bid you all Dark Greetings! Some scrappy, ragtag underdog tale, some pugilistic match where were the goodhearted gladiator who brings down the oppressive regime that put him in the arena. Episode 15 of Star Wars: The Batch features a summit of high ranking Imperials coming together to talk about the future of the Empire. Compensation for the families of those who had been unjustly executed? Such a prospect was too much for many Imperial personnel to ignore, and so they abandoned their previous allegiance to the Empire and either went into hiding or became active in the movements that would later coalesce into the Rebel Alliance. And of course, if the bad guys didn't keep causing trouble, we'd never do anything remotely unpleasant. io9 Published an AI-Generated Star Wars Article Filled With Errors Sadly even the United States government still has the power to draft its citizens into war, though that hasn't happened for decades. We only do bad things when the bad guys (i.e., everyone who opposes us) force us to. If you're looking at Legends Material, though, you have to look at Baron Soontir Fel, who clearly felt he was doing GOOD WORK through the galaxy by helping to maintain order and equality. Even after the destruction of Alderaan, she viewed the Empire as a career opportunity, and it took witnessing Imperial crimes first hand for theCalamaricredit to drop in Maela's mind. He defects that night. The victors always write the history books. Even after Alderaan was blown to bits, the inhabitants of the galaxy still didn't consider the Empire an entirely evil regime in Star Wars. However, at some level there are people who are sadistic and enjoy enforcing that order. And the former was largely a fraud, trying to be something he really wasn't. Did any planet, system, or regional governor think the Empire was good for them? Watch on Everyone familiar with Star Wars knows that the Empire is bad, and the Rebellion is good. He had made himself lord of all he surveyed, but he had much to learn. traitorous first chairman Prince Bail Organa and the rebellion for $66 at Amazon. Star Wars: All 9 Factions In The Skywalker Saga Explained - Screen Rant Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out because I was not a trade unionist. The Best Star Wars Vehicle Builds In Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom Now 33% Off. The more I've thought about this, the more I have struggled to come up with an answer based on anything actually depicted in the films themselves. opposing the Emperor and thereby destroying everything they had, even In the role playing game they address the "Destroyer" class in a completely different way saying that ships with that name are more like dreadnaughts and capital ships, and that the name "Star Destroyer" was taken specifically to cause fear and not a particular class although I would like to see a "Hugs and Kisses Ship". Even though it's the invisible fabric of everyone's daily life, commerce doesn't really seem to exist in the Star Wars universe at all, but one way the Empire could be ruining people's lives is by controlling what gets bought, sold, or traded; dictating prices; or by taxing everything so much that even basic necessities become impossible to afford. by Amy Ratcliffe. Princess Leia is taken prisoner aboard the Death Star and forced to watch helplessly as her home planet of Alderaan is destroyed by the maiden firing of the Death Star's primary weapon. And each of them probably had no idea that Darth Sidious was a Sith. In what ways was the Windows NT POSIX implementation unsuited to real use? Star Wars: The Most Dangerous Types Of Stormtroopers, Ranked - Screen Rant And when Padme says This is how liberty dies, with thunderous applause, she gets to the real issue here. An Imperial comms officer grows suspicious when he discovers that their signals are. Even if they didnt start evil, they were brainwashed and indoctrinated into it. Why do you say the Imperial forces are the bad guys? That's a form of slavery that many real-world governments have used throughout history. Star Wars Reveals the Rebels Weaponized the Media Against Emperor - CBR Their actions make sense to them, as a means to accomplish goals they feel are worth-while. Of course "Death Star" still strikes most people as a much more frightening, vicious, and unapologetically aggressive name, and - as explained above - many formerly loyal Imperials defected when they learned of the plans to build the first Death Star. While the Imperialis was stolen by the gambler Lando Calrissian and wrecked on the moon Quantxi, the Emperor had several replicas of the vessel housed at his Observatories, which were scattered throughout the galaxy. The Galactic Empire was a chance to make a government that worked. Sure, behind closed doors, Emperor Palpatine is secretly a Sith Lord who can shoot light bolts from his hands. They probably don't even think that they're the "bad guys". Imperialis | Wookieepedia | Fandom rev2023.7.13.43531. Even if we are forced to maintain control by using force and instilling fear, the ends justify the means. So, the "Imperial military", while headed by the insidious Darth Sidious, is, mostly, your average Imperial citizens. I imagine his propaganda would play well with anyone who doesn't have detailed insider knowledge about what was actually going on. More:Star Wars: The Droid Luke DIDN'T Buy Secretly Saved The Galaxy, Star Wars: Han & Leia Calling Their Son Ben Doesn't Make Sense, Star Wars: The Droid Luke DIDN'T Buy Secretly Saved The Galaxy, Cars But Not Pens: All The Muggle Technology The Wizarding World Actually Uses In Harry Potter, Hugh Jackman's Wolverine Costumes, Ranked, Gollum Killed Frodo's Parents? Said officers, stormtroopers, bounty hunters, and others seem to take his comments right in stride rather than being shocked by his blatant display of evilness. Why do you say the Imperial forces are the bad guys? No. Do Stormtroopers or Imperial officers receive vacation? - Greenstone Walker Nov 30, 2015 at 23:15 27 The difference between a patriot, a rebel and an insurgent is point of view. Even if they had, would it have mattered to them personally? In the end, I'd expect most people would be more shocked by the target itself (a peaceful, safe planet), rather than the death toll - kind of like people were absolutely outraged by the terrorist attack on Paris recently, even though this kind of thing happens all the time elsewhere in the world. But he would deal with any who chose to challenge him with the same precision he had applied to exterminating the Jedi. The ISB agent says: Hes not the only one who lost people, Ronnadam snapped, but then his expression grew more thoughtful. Everyone familiar with Star Wars knows that the Empire is bad, and the Rebellion is good. While a couple of his Imperial stormtroopers watched. Sometimes that got to her when nothing else did. I think they know it. And that probably means that there are a lot of laws and regulations making various goods and services costly or illegal. - ibid. There will of course be a penalty to be paid, but if Lieutenant Kyrell returns to duty in short order, he can continue his career without undue difficulty. And however bad the things we do might be, we're still better than the bad guys. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Eventually the dark side would grant him infallible foresight, but until such time future events would remain just out of clear sight, clouded by possibilities and the unremitting swirlings of the Force. - Darth Vader to Luke, The Empire Strikes Back. No, the Empire isn't evil from that perspective - its just trying to hold together the galaxy after the chaos of the clone wars, and preventing it from descending further into chaos by providing a much needed order. But I suspect that the Emperor's stance was, at least in part, "Once I have a Death Star, I can afford to lay my cards on the table, because wait for it BECAUSE I WILL HAVE A DEATH STAR. And then there would always be some members of the public who are incapable of thinking that their own government could do wrong so live instead in denial. Maela's mother could see through the Empire's facade, but was still forced into serving them (albeit indirectly) through poverty. Updated Jan 1, 2021 Despite their legendarily bad aim, stormtroopers are actually specialized in a lot of areas, which is why there are so many different types of them. Which does seem to be the case: Once word of the world's fate got out, Clearly, so many Imperial troops defected after the destruction of Alderaan that the Empire was forced to be lenient in its handling of defection, in the hopes of getting some of these valuable personnel back. Stack Exchange network consists of 182 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Still, we're also in this for ourselves. - Imperial Admiral Rae Sloane and her captive, Wedge Antilles, Aftermath. another world. You highlight some very interesting points in this post, and I agree with you to an extent. An enormous increase in defections from the Empire took place shortly after work began on the first Death Star, with countless scientists and technical personnel fleeing the base where the battle station was being built: Motivated by grievances against the Empire, many had fled and become fugitives. Generally no. - Star Wars: Tarkin. In the Star Wars Universe, the Rebellion deployed many tactics to try to break the Empire.They used spies, straight-up guerilla warfare, and the Jedi power of Luke Skywalker to give them the upper hand. Aside from a small group of perceptive individuals (like Padme, Bail Organa, and Mon Mothma), we get the impression that during the reign of the Empire the average person (citizen or officer) might believe that the Empire was in the right. Citizens of the Empire aren't secure in their possessions and property. The Empire hurt people close to me. Wait, we just lost the war? Revenge of the Sith star wars: the bad batch star wars: the clone wars Star Wars: The Force Awakens star wars: the mandalorian star wars: . No matter how hard you work to beat us back, we are an infection inside the galaxys bones. Probably most common among mid-tier and rank-and-file Imperials who had been indoctrinated into the Imperial mindset and didn't question it. In 5 ABY, the bounty hunter . Throughout Episode IV, V and VI, we view the Rebel Alliance as a force for good, the little guys fighting the super bad Imperial baddies. The Empire had little interest in learning the ways and tongues of other cultures. "Eyes of the Empire" highlights two very different perspectives of the Empire from regular folks in theStar Wars universe, instead of the usual Jedi, princesses and maverick pilots. Then they came for me, and there was no one left to speak out for me. . Did the 501st Legion know what Anakin had become when they attacked the Jedi Temple with him? Once he acquired political control over the Galaxy, did he ban gay marriage? It's only to be expected in a bureaucracy that's not evil (and to a degree in an evil one as well). [Opinion] Imperials really aren't as bad as everyone says they are There always seems to be a stereotype especially from casual fans, that the empire and it's members are pure evil, but this is very far from the truth. Help. Most people don't want to invade other countries. Before World War II, destroyers were light vessels with little endurance for unattended ocean operations; typically a number of destroyers and a single destroyer tender operated together. The movies offer surprisingly little information as to what's actually wrong with Imperial rule. I am merely a public official. But that assumes some kind of property rights, and that's never fully established in that world. 4.8 out of 5 stars with 330 ratings. The Imperial Eraalso known as the Age of the Empire, and sometimes regarded as the Dark Times or the reign of the Empirewas the time period that covered the reign of the Galactic Empire, lasting from Galactic Emperor Sheev Palpatine's proclamation of the New Order in 19 BBY until the signing of the Galactic Concordance in 5 ABY. And apart from Padme's interminable dialogue about Senatorial procedure in the Prequels, there's almost no discussion of governing philosophy in the entire series. What makes life under Emperor Palpatine so unbearable, and what would make life under the New Republic so much better, for the ordinary citizens of the galaxy? On the contrary, he has been tireless in his devotion to unify the galaxy and assure the well-being of its myriad populations. Yupe Tashu, a non-Force-user, fancied himself a historian and occultist of the Sith, and served as an advisor to Palpatine. "Good" and "evil" depend on the values of the speaker. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, except for material where copyright is reserved by a party other than FEE. An AI-generated story about Star Wars on Gizmodo's io9, which was filled with errors, appears to have been the work of parent company G/O Media. Why didn't the Imperials block the exhaust port on the Death Star during the Battle of Yavin? Unfortunately, Star Wars never actually wrestles with these issues in any meaningful way. What is it that he's actually imposing on his citizens that requires multiple planet-destroying superweapons to enforce? By the time people hear about it and get upset, I'll be able to blow their planets up if they complain, so who cares what people think?". Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. For the most part, his brutality seems to be limited to confrontations with the Rebel Alliance. There is nothing ominous of their name any more than other ship class names. Youre not just demanding submission, youre generating evil., Teller stared up at him. Word for experiencing a sense of humorous satisfaction in a shared problem.
Who Owns Ravinia Communities, Laws On Calling Out Of Work, Do Narcissists Take Your Money, Why Does Margaux Kill Ben In Revenge, Articles A